Out of all the different types of shoes for women, flats are supposed to be the easiest, most comfortable option. But if you have wide feet, it can be hard to find a pair that doesn’t pinch or rub.
That doesn’t mean you have to settle. The best flats for wide feet deliver on comfort, support, and style—think roomy toe boxes, soft insoles, and designs that work with your feet, not against them.
We’ve rounded up nine of our favorite flats to help you step out in confidence and say goodbye to sore toes.
9 comfortable flats that won’t pinch or squeeze wide feet
Whether you’re looking for the best-fitting shoes to wear with a maxi dress or dressing up for work, these comfortable flat shoes for wide feet are proof that support and style can go hand in hand.
The best part? Many of these styles are available at budget-friendly prices on ThredUp—you can even save your preferred shoe size and width, making it easier than ever to find perfect-fitting flats.
1. Everlane The Day Glove
Crafted from buttery-soft nappa leather, these wide-foot flats are as sleek as they are supportive. The Day Glove from Everlane features a flattering almond toe, leather sole with rubber traction spots, and a cushioned insole for all-day ease. And since the leather molds to your foot over time, buying them preloved on ThredUp often means they’re already broken in and extra comfy.
Thrift Everlane flats on ThredUp, starting at $29.99.
2. Rothy’s The Point Flat
Sometimes, sizing up is all it takes to find a shoe that fits. These chic pointed-toe flats are a cult favorite for a reason—with just a half-size bump, they’re a comfy go-to for wide feet. Rothy’s The Point features a flexible recycled knit upper, a bendy rubber sole, and a cushioned, removable insole that adds comfort without bulk. With sizes ranging from 5 to 13 and tons of colors and patterns to choose from, Rothy’s truly has something for everyone.
Thrift Rothy’s flats on ThredUp, starting at $12.99.
3. Birdies The Starling Flat
The Starling Flat from Birdies takes its cue from slippers, with a quilted satin footbed, built-in arch support, and a sturdy rubber sole to keep things grounded. While Birdies doesn’t always offer dedicated wide-width sizing, the Starling Flat’s relaxed shape and soft materials make these flats a win for broader feet.
Thrift Birdies on ThredUp, starting at $14.99.
4. Allbirds Flats
Made with breathable merino wool or airy eucalyptus fiber, Allbirds Flats are lightweight, flexible, and perfect for everyday wear. The signature SweetFoam™ soles offer just the right amount of bounce, making these cute flats for wide feet an easy choice for running errands or dressing up casual looks. Available in sizes 5 to 11 and a range of earthy, go-with-everything shades, Allbirds’ soft, stretchy materials make them a comfy pick for wide-footed thrifters.
Thrift Allbirds flats on ThredUp, starting at $19.99.
5. Vivaia Pointed Toe Flats
If you’re after something polished yet practical, Vivaia‘s pointed-toe flats deliver style without the squeeze. Their sleek silhouette hides a subtly wider toe box, making them perfect for wide feet. Crafted with stretchy recycled knit fabrics and designed with cushioned insoles and flexible rubber soles, these are flats you’ll actually wear from morning ’til night. The Vivaia Pointed Toe Flats are available in solid shades like classic black and bold red in sizes 5 to 11.
Thrift Vivaia flats on ThredUp, starting at $25.99.
6. Sam Edelman Ballet Flats
Keep an eye out for Sam Edelman‘s Felicia Ballet Flat, a fan favorite you can often find on ThredUp in wider widths. With a soft leather or suede upper and a roomy, rounded toe box, these ballet flats for wide feet are all about easy, everyday comfort. An elasticized edge keeps them snug (but never tight), while a plush footbed cushions every step. The Felicia Ballet Flat is available in a rainbow of colors and prints—from timeless black to bold animal patterns—in sizes 5 to 11.
Thrift Sad Edelman flats on ThredUp, starting at $11.99.
7. Naturalizer Flats
Known for their comfort-first designs, Naturalizer makes some of the best flats for wide feet, with cushioned insoles, flexible construction, and a variety of foot-friendly materials. Whether you’re keeping it classic for work or going bold for brunch, you can find Naturalizer Flats in a wide range of colors and patterns for every vibe.
Thrift Naturalizer flats on ThredUp, starting at $26.99.
8. Salvatore Ferragamo Flats
If you’re looking for a luxury option for a special event, Salvatore Ferragamo Flats are a timeless pick. Crafted from buttery leather or velvety suede and often topped with the brand’s signature grosgrain bow, these flats feel as elevated as they look. Certain styles—like the iconic Vara flat—offer a bit more room, making them a stylish option for slightly wider feet. You’ll find flats from Salvatore Ferragamo in classic shades like black, navy, and burgundy, plus seasonal hues and occasional patterns.
Thrift Salvatore Ferragamo flats on ThredUp, starting at $33.99.
9. Birkenstock Sandals
Birkenstock sandals are beloved for a reason—their anatomically shaped footbeds and wide-width options make them one of the best flats for wide feet, hands down. With adjustable straps in natural leather or durable Birko-Flor™, these casual favorites offer a custom-feel fit and all-day support. You’ll find Birkenstocks in earthy tones like brown, tan, and black, with seasonal colors and fun patterns sometimes available.
Thrift Birkenstock sandals on ThredUp, starting at $30.99.
How to pick shoes for wide feet
If your shoes constantly pinch, squeeze, or leave your feet feeling sore by day’s end, it might be time to check your width. Dealing with pressure at the ball of the foot or the dreaded “spilling over the sides” look? Those are classic wide-feet woes. If you suspect your feet are on the wider side, look for sizes labeled with a “W,” “D,” or “EE” to find your perfect fit.
Keep these key tips in mind when you’re on the hunt for cute flats for wide feet:
- Know your width: If you’ve been squeezing into standard widths, getting your feet measured by a pro will help you shop for wide-foot shoes that go with everything—and actually fit.
- Consider the toe box: That too-fight feeling up front? It could mean the toe box shape just isn’t right. If sharply pointed-toe styles feel more like toe traps, try flats with rounded or square toe boxes for extra wiggle room. They’re especially good for warmer days when your feet need space to breathe.
- Material matters: Look for comfortable flat shoes for wide feet made from flexible materials like stretchy knits, soft leather, or buttery suede. These materials mold to your foot more easily, skipping the painful break-in period—especially key if you’re looking for shoes for clubbing or anything else that keeps you on your feet.
Give your feet (and wallet) a break with ThredUp’s flats for wide feet
Finding truly comfortable flats for wide feet doesn’t have to mean spending a fortune or sacrificing style. On ThredUp, you can score gently used, name-brand flats that fit just right, for way less than retail. From cushioned insoles to reliable arch support, the preloved styles on ThredUp check every box—without the brand-new price tag.
Whether you’re after shoes that go with wide-leg pants or the perfect pair for bootcut jeans, ThredUp has you (and your feet) covered.
FAQs
Can people with wide feet wear ballet flats?
Yes, people with wide feet can wear ballet flats—the trick is to find pairs designed with a wider toe box or made from flexible materials like soft leather or knit. Some even come in true wide widths, with bonus features like arch support for extra comfort.
Which women’s shoe brands run wide?
Brands like Vivaia, Everlane, Sam Edelman, ASOS Design, and Margaux are top picks for wide-foot flats that combine style with comfort. You can thrift many of them on ThredUp—just use the Width filter to zero in on your best fit.
Are ballet flats supposed to be tight?
No, ballet flats for broad feet aren’t supposed to feel restrictive. While they’re designed to fit snugly enough to stay on without slipping, ballet flats shouldn’t feel tight or pinch your toes. Your feet should rest naturally in the toe box, with enough space to flex and breathe. The right pair will mold to your foot’s shape without squeezing or causing discomfort.
Should I size up if I have wide feet?
While it sometimes works, sizing up isn’t always the answer. Shoes that are too long can slip at the heel and throw off your stride. Instead, look for styles marked specifically as wide widths; they’re built with extra room where it counts, like in the toe box and across the ball of the foot. Skip the guesswork—use ThredUp’s Width filter to find your next pair of comfortable flats.
Copywriting Portfolio 
Leave a comment